Who should bat 3rd?

Who should replace Lee in the 3 hole going into next year?

Obviously Koyie Hill and the Hoff are obvious choices and the clear favorites so I decided to leave them off to give the other guys a chance to get a couple votes.

I vote Colvin. Simply because between him and Soriano he is LH.

I don't want Soriano, but worse, batting 3rd.

Ideally, I think it would have to be Soriano.

Castro

Byrd

Soriano

Ramirez

Colvin/Fukudome

DeWitt

Half-power/Lady

Hill

Pitcher

Quote:

Originally Posted by Milnertime

I don't want Soriano, but worse, batting 3rd.

Ideally, I think it would have to be Soriano.

Castro

Byrd

Soriano

Ramirez

Colvin/Fukudome

DeWitt

Half-power/Lady

Hill

Pitcher

I think Soriano and Colvin are both ideal for the 3 hitter. High slugging lots of power, low OBP.

i only want Colvin because he is our only LHH in the lineup

I voted Soto, maybe give him a confidence boost.

Castro

Colvin

Soto

Let the young guns do the dirty work

I had to go with Soriano in this situation, although it was a hard decision between him, Ramierez and Byrd. Colvin should be 5th or lower, Soto is probably the same

I'll go on record now as to what I think the 2011 line up will be:

Castro

Byrd

A Ram

Carlos Pena

Soriano

Soto

Colvin

DeWitt

If Castro and Byrd get on base at a decent clip, say hello to waay less one run losses.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ReJo

Who should replace Lee in the 3 hole going into next year?

Obviously Koyie Hill and the Hoff are obvious choices and the clear favorites so I decided to leave them off to give the other guys a chance to get a couple votes.

In what f'ed up universe would Koyie Hill be an obvious choice to bat third in a line up? I wouldn't hit him 3rd in our slow-pitch softball lineup.

I pray to God that this was a joke....